Friday's Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra program saw a drop
in attendance from the average so far this season. But that average has been higher than in
previous seasons, and we had neither music director Krzysztof Urbański to
conduct nor a big display piece, either of which seems needed to draw them
in. Our guest conductor, Miguel Harth-Bedoya
Harth-Bedoya(47, from Peru), led the orchestra in two repertoire works of
Ravel and Strauss while soprano Twyla Robinson sang five early songs of Strauss
and the short song cycle Shéhérazade
Harth-Bedoya opened with Ravel's well known Rapsodie Espagnole, completed in 1908,
the same year as Debussy's Iberia,
the stronger of the two works in evoking the essence of Spain (let's schedule
it). The Rapsodie is cast into four parts: "Prélude à la nuit," "Malagueña,"
"Habañera" and "Feria"--with a very short pause between each. Starting with the strings intoning a soft,
descending line, the piece remains very soft through its early parts, with loud
interjections increasing in frequency, such that "Feria" ends on a thunderous
Harth-Bedoya had his players in good control throughout the
four parts, especially handling the climaxes well. He took "Malagueña" at a nimble pace while
cutting the tempo considerably for "Habañera"--more either way than I'm used to,
but nonetheless it worked. He began
"Feria" with his players displaying excellent precision, but a bit less so
toward the climactic end.
Twyla Robinson, a 1993 graduate of Centenary College of
Louisiana, though widely acclaimed, failed to deliver in her appearance
here. She sang five songs from Richard
Strauss's Op. 10 (1882) and Op. 27 (1894) series.
Lasting about ten minutes, they lack the profundity of his famous Four Last Songs of 1948. Following intermission Robinson returned to
sing Ravel's ten-minute, three-song cycle Shéhérazade. Throughout her singing, Robinson displayed a
very wide, very rapid vibrato. It was
especially unsettling to hear her in Ravel's second song "La Flûte Enchantée,"
wherein ISO principal flutist Karen Moratz made beautiful sounds against
Robinson's wobbling intonation.
Isn't Strauss's Suite to his opera Der Rosenkavalier (1911) just another Don Juan with waltzes thrown in?
Conductor Artur Rodziński probably wouldn't agree, as he fashioned
the Suite with the composer's approval in 1944. Yet there are similarities
between Strauss's first tone-poem masterpiece (1889) and the Suite -- as well as
differences. Don Juan is masterfully knit together; it's all of a piece while
the suite has its parts strung together, capturing Strauss's Viennese waltzes (by
the way, Richard Strauss was German and had no relation to the Viennese waltz
kings, Johann and Johann Jr.). The last
part of the Suite contains the Trio music, the most beautiful part of the opera
and which ends it. But Rodziński
tacked on another waltz to give the piece a final hurrah.
With careful control of dynamics, excellent solo work -- especially
the trumpet-- and an agreeable pace, Harth-Bedoya made the Suite a rousing
finish to the concert. Feb. 20; Hilbert Circle Theatre