If there's one band that best represents American Rock music in the past 30 years, I'd give the title to Tom Petty & the Heartbreakers. Sounding not from one place (belying the band's strong Florida roots), but from everywhere, that enables them to connect with rednecks and hippies, east coast attitude and west coast gleam. They can rock loud. Tom can be acoustic quiet. Lyrics resonate. They can sweat and smile at the same time. It is a band that has been making music for almost 40 years, with a new album, Mojo, released last month. It's both a departure and rejuvinating set of music. I'm a big E Street Band and Pearl Jam fan, but still give the nod to Petty and his boys.
The band hops off the tour buses and onto the Verizon Wireless/Deer Creek Music Center stage in Noblesville Saturday night, for a couple hours of hits and new stuff. They'll pull a few from Mojo to play, but a lot will be from their deep catalog of iconic classic rock songs.
Here's a list of Petty's 7 Essential Albums (and a couple that were too good to leave off).
2. Hard Promises (1981) - Many critics consider the followup to Damn the Torpodoes even better than it's predecessor. The songs are more ambitious, deeper lyrically, and a bit more mature. Many have been concert staples since the 1981 release, but simply looking at the titles ("A Woman in Love") tells you they weren't radio smashes like the previous record's songs. And in 1981, it was all about radio airplay. Not that hits = a great record, but it is slightly less powerful than the record that came before it.
ESSENTIALS: "The Waiting, "Insider", "Something Big"
HIDDEN GEMS: "A Thing About You", "Letting You Go"
3. Full Moon Fever (1989) - Shine it up, Jeff Lynne, and let's take it on the road! The ELO mastermind had Tom drop most of the band (except for the liberal use of Campbell) and crafted a smash hit. The hard-edged heartland rock of Petty's previous few records was augmented by a California shine, created by banks of acoustic guitars, ELO background vocals and drums that sound like they have tambourines attached to the snare. I find nothing wrong with the record; I've played it hundreds of times. It is a slice of brilliance. Listen to the album; There's a musical sweetness that was never again duplicated, though he would try, with mixed results, on his next record, Into the Great Wide Open.
ESSENTIALS: "Running Down a Dream", "Free Fallin'", "Long is a Long Road". "Running Down a Dream", "I Won't Back Down"
HIDDEN GEMS: "The Apartment Song", "Dependin' on You"
5. You're Gonna Get it (1978) The best of his early period, and listening back to it as I write this, it is one of his great albums. They took the template of The Cars - or The Cars stole it from Petty - and made the first part of the leap from new wave to straight up rock and roll. Even a buried cut like "No Second Thoughts" shows the progression, sounding like a cut from Exile on Main Street. The album was an essential indicator that Tom Petty & the Heartbreakers were as good as anybody else in 1978.
ESSENTIALS: "Listen to Her Heart", "I Need to Know". "When the Time Comes"
HIDDEN GEMS: "Hurt", "Magnolia"
6. The Live Anthology (2010) - With 58 songs, it could be overkill, and it isn't one you will sit down to listen straight through. But it very much is an album that you can drop into the car CD player, and choose a random track - or hit the shuffle on the iPod - and you will never be disappointed. Never. Hits like "Free Fallin'" and "Breakdown" are one it, but so are winners like "Louisiana Rain" from Damn the Torpedoes, "Have Love, Will Travel" (one of the few keepers from The Last DJ ) and "Oh Well", a song from Fleetwood Mac that later became a hit for the Rockets in the late 70's. It is a sprawling testement to what American rock and roll should sound like. The album encapsulates everything musically righteous about a band that not only made essential records, but celebrated them while playing live for the past 35 years.
ESSENTIALS: Most of it
HIDDEN GEMS: The rest
Three for the road (Honorable Mentions)
Wildflowers (1994) - His second album minus the Heartbreakers, it is an organic and surprisingly lively rock and roll record. "You Don't Know How it Feels" is a TP classic, and "You Wreck Me" should be. It's 15 songs of mostly acoustic guitar-driven tunes and Tom's voice. The title cut is one of his best love songs.
Into the Great Wide Open (1991) - Some great tunes (trademark Petty like "Learning to Fly" and the title cut) with some rockers ("Makin' Some Noise", "Kings Highway") that all kinda pale in comparison to the previous album's output, the ginormous Full Moon Fever. To me, it's a record that was lacking some passion. Drop it into another year in his catalog (say 1999), and it might feel different/stronger. Still one of his better ones.
Pack Up the Plantation (Live) (1986) - A bit bloated, I will say that. Not sure TP and the band needed a horn section. But in the mid 80's, it still sounded good, because we couldn't hop on the web and find a bootleg version of last Thursday show. We needed live albums to hear the rough side of a band, and this one was a sloppy, yet endearing momento of the road-weary rockers . Includes "American Girl", Refugee", "The Waiting" and Bbreakdown", but still can't call it a a greatest hits record. The single from the album was a loving cover of The Searchers' "Needles and Pins", with official Heartbreaker groupie, Stevie Nicks.