South of Chicago: Windy-city style pizza 

click to enlarge Chicago-style deep dish pizza. Photo by Mark Lee.
  • Chicago-style deep dish pizza. Photo by Mark Lee.

My brother and I have equal affinity for deep dish pizza, the Chicago Bears and our Italian heritage. When Kurt heard about South of Chicago, a pizza place that opened in a humble Fountain Square storefront earlier this spring, we hot-footed it over. Here is the resulting conversation:

Kurt: This place is covered in Bears, Bulls, Cubs, Sox and Blackhawks stuff.

Anne: The only Colts paraphernalia is a 2006 Colts vs. Bears Super Bowl poster. They're showing a smidgen of respect.

Kurt: You wouldn't fly the American flag at Olive Garden, would you? This is about Chicago.

[The air fills with the sounds of nostalgic buzzers from the Game Show Network on TV and energetic jack-hammering on the south leg of The Cultural Trail on the sidewalk outside.]

Anne: How do we describe the deep dish of our dreams?

Kurt: Crust that's firm, flaky and buttery. A crust stub that I look forward to eating.

Anne: My fantasy crust involves quite a bit of cornmeal and is crunchy on the outside but chewy within. The crust needs to be golden and it needs to bear the mark of hand-shaping, with a fairly high wall.

[Kurt uses the "flick test" on the crust of our South of Chicago pie: a healthy tapping sound is heard. The crust bears signs of thumbprints - another plus - though the wall is not that high.]

Kurt: Pizza sauce should also be something I'd want to eat by itself. The chunkier the better.

Anne: This sauce is not that chunky, but very tomato-y, with a sprinkling of parmesan and dried herbs.

Kurt: The only thing that's possible to overdo in a deep-dish pizza is cheese. You don't want what tastes like a big mouthful of hacked-up emphysematic phlegm.

[The South of Chicago pizza has no bites of solid cheese, thus respecting the fellow toppings of garlic, olives, vibrant green fresh spinach, and clearly un-canned mushrooms. The first five toppings are free at South of Chicago. Deep dish is available in a cute personal size, and as a 14-incher, which feeds three for $15.99; drinks are included. Kurt bites into an Italian Beef sandwich that we also ordered, dry, with about two shots of herbed jus on the side.]

Kurt: Wow, this is prime. Very thinly sliced beef on a cushiony bun.

Anne: A nice peppery finish to each bite. Bread that's soft, not tough.

[The owners, Bob and Beverly, each come to check on us a few times. They are from Chicago but have lived in Indy sixteen years. They seem passionate about their work and eager to please.]

Kurt: I hazard to say we've found the best deep dish south of Soldier Field.

Related Locations


Readers also liked…

Around the Web

This Week's Flyers

About The Author

Anne Laker

Today's Best Bets | All of today's events

Around the Web

All contents copyright © 2017 NUVO Inc.
3951 N. Meridian St., Suite 200, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Website powered by Foundation