The rock musical Next to Normal
is a dichotomy of heartbreaking and hopeful. Brian Yorkey (book and lyrics) and Tom Kitt (music), part of the team behind If/Then
, crafted this show, which won the 2010 Pulitzer Prize and was nominated for the 2009 Tony Award for Best Musical. Their story gives audiences insight into the painful effects of mental illness on a family — in this case, the mother, who was diagnosed as bipolar and experiences hallucinations.
Carmel Community Players' production of this raw narrative is spot on. Carlo Nepomuceno (also the director) and Bill Fitch's set design is minimal but effective, letting the audience's full attention rest on the actors. Various levels segregate spaces and allow simultaneous events to take place in different locations. Nepomuceno utilizes the cast's talent to fill in the gaps.
Talent is in no short supply here. Georgeanna Teipen, as Diana, the mother, gives a powerful performance. Teipen's Diana never comes across as a slave to her illness, even when she attempts suicide, which from her perspective seems logical, and then when ECT treatments rob her of most of her memories.
Diana's husband and daughter are worse for the wear after living with her oddities for the last 16 years. Russell Watson, as her husband Dan, expresses the longtime suffering of a man who is devoted to his wife but doesn'tt really know how to help her. Watson's Dan is the most sympathetic character, as he portrays the patience and helplessness of his situation.
Sharmaine Ruth, as their daughter Natalie, combines the typical difficulty of being a teenager with the added burden of her family life. Ruth shows how angry Natalie is but how lonely and sad. Daniel Hellman, as her sweet boyfriend Dan, is the most stable element in her life, and she doesn't know how to accept that kind of love.
Kyle Mottinger plays the crux of the family's dysfunction: The specter of Gabe. His rocking "I'm Alive" demands notice, symbolizing the relentless, inescapable nature of mental illness and grief, which his character represents.
Toward the end, Diana says, "Most people who think they are happy haven't thought about it enough." Diana was diagnosed after only four months of grieving over a lost infant. The subtext in this show questions what is normal. As Natalie states later, maybe we should all accept that the more realistic goal should be something "next
through Aug. 21, Carmel Community Players, Clay Terrace, $15 - 16, Carmelplayers.org