Review: ISO Symphonic Hits Program No. 6 

****
click to enlarge Xian Zhang
  • Xian Zhang

Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra, Hilbert Circle Theatre, Oct. 28-29

A few weeks ago, the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra presented a complete performance of Carl Orff's Carmina Burana, a 20th-century vocal/choral work, and filled the Circle to a near sell-out. This Friday's concert featured both the Schumann A Minor Piano Concerto and Tchaikovsky's Fifth symphony, war-horse standards extraordinaire, and saw a paltry turnout. Was it the World Series' game 7 pulling away symphony-goers in those numbers? One would suspect a demographic more diverse in its pursuits - but who knows?

Chinese conductor Xian Zhang served as the podium guest, and German Till Felner was the pianist for the Schumann. Zhang provided a podium powerhouse; she gave Schumann's bland orchestration some flair not usually encountered in more typical readings.

39-year-old Felner jumped into the fray with those opening cascading chords. From there throughout the miraculous first movement, we heard the two give Schumann's most inspired writing a unanimity of purpose, of conception, of execution. Though Felner's pianism did not show any prominent tempo or dynamic nuance, his consistency with Zhang's orchestra seemed to compensate to a fair degree. His deft handling of the notes, measures and phrases, notably in the first-movement cadenza -- Schumann's keyboard-writing peak -- impressed without causing one to forget what came before.

Zhang began her program with a five-minute trifle: the Overture to Vincenzo Bellini's opera I Capuletti e i Montecchi (The Capulets and the Montegues, 1830) - a lighter take on Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet story. Evidently, Bellini, who popularized the "bel canto" singing style, liked shorter overtures than his predecessor Rossini, who, just a year earlier, had written his 15-minute Overture to William Tell. This was the last opera he would compose, despite having more than half his life yet to live.

Tchaikovsky's Symphony No. 5 in E Minor, Op. 64 occupies the middle of the symphonic triptych which places the Russian composer in the top tier of Romantic symphonists. Though I would rate his No. 6 - the "Pathétique" - as his symphonic masterpiece, Tchaikovsky had plenty going for him in No. 4 and No. 5. For No. 5 we have the lovely horn solo opening its second movement - Andante cantabile - beautifully played by ISO principal hornist Robert Danforth.

But then we also have what is often called the "Providence" motive: dominating, linking and transforming itself throughout its four movements. Zhang took a measured tempo as compared with many typical performances, but I would only have preferred a faster reading during the Finale's bravura Allegro vivace section, which should always be taken at a swift pace. Otherwise Zhang made her tempi convincing with her control of the symphony's dynamics. Her account was wholly satisfying, if not quite memorable.

Related Locations

Comments

Around the Web

This Week's Flyers

About The Author

Tom Aldridge

Today's Best Bets | All of today's events

Around the Web

All contents copyright © 2016 NUVO Inc.
3951 N. Meridian St., Suite 200, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Website powered by Foundation