Review: Bat Boy The Musical 

"The show is filled with astonishing mullets, melodramatic secrets, outrageous songs, a glowing cross, and British pantomime-inspired characters"

click to enlarge rail.jpg

I said it before in 2002 when Bat Boy: The Musical had its round in Indianapolis at the Phoenix Theatre, and I am going to say it again: Any show that includes a stuffed-animal orgy has got to get all kinds of props. Nothing is quite like watching interspecies animal hand puppets banging on each other while the god Pan encourages them in song. (Interesting side note: Not only was Pan renowned for his sexual prowess, but he was also considered the god of theatrical criticism by the Greeks.)

Theatre on the Square is presenting this campy musical for its third Indianapolis staging, this time under the direction of Zach Neiditch. While the above-mentioned scene is perhaps the funniest, there is more. The show is filled with astonishing mullets, melodramatic secrets, outrageous songs, a glowing cross, and British pantomime-inspired characters (as in cross-dressing). Most people are familiar with the 1992 Weekly World News series, and the musical aims to shed some light on Bat Boy's origins in a dust speck of a hick town in West Virginia.

Of course, the star of the show is Bat Boy, who is soon renamed Edgar, portrayed by Justin Klein. Klein does a spectacular job of transitioning from a cave-dwelling, grunting wild child to an eloquent, proper young man, complete with a British accent. Not only is his transformation remarkable, but he occasionally lets the Bat Boy's mannerisms slip out when he is scared or confused. This nuanced piece of theatricality reminds the audience of Bat Boy's duel with his new persona.

Bat Boy is flanked by the town veterinarian Thomas (Dave Ruark, who was also in the 2002 production but in a different role), his wife Meredith (Mindy Morton), and their teenage daughter Shelley (Devan Mathias). Ruark captures Thomas' gradual decent into murderous mayhem while enabling Bat Boy's thirst for blood. His vocals were a bit sharp Saturday night, but I've seen Ruark in scores of productions, and I'm betting that he just had an off night. Morton is perfect as the long-suffering wife, and Mathias' mixture of angst and idealism reflects a teen to a T.

My only nitpicks are the small areas the cast had to work with and the mics being turned on and off for songs and dialogue respectively. The stage felt cramped during large numbers, and while the mics picked up the actors' voices beautifully, I was too aware of the switch. However, that could easily just be me being a nag.

If you can't get enough of Bat Boy, you are in luck: The Weekly World News reported on a new Bat Boy film back in March. Check it out at

Through May 21, $15-20,

Around the Web


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

This Week's Flyers

Today's Best Bets | All of today's events

Around the Web

All contents copyright © 2016 NUVO Inc.
3951 N. Meridian St., Suite 200, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Website powered by Foundation