Jersey Boys: Oh, what a drag 

click to enlarge jerseyboysmovieimage.jpg

When the closing credits for Jersey Boys begin to roll, the actors/singers playing The Four Seasons perform the hit "December 1963 (Oh, What a Night)." It's presented as a full-fledged Broadway style song and dance number, complete with appearances from other notable cast members. The production brims with a sense of vitality missing from most of the film. Oh, what a shame.

Jersey Boys is director Clint Eastwood's take on the hit Broadway musical based on the story of The Four Seasons. Though the film includes performances of a lot of the group's chart-topping tunes, it is not a musical. Eastwood's adaptation is more a standard-issue biopic, with desaturated colors used to give it a period feel.

Eastwood's decision to pair upbeat music with a downbeat story is interesting, but the movie feels too much like a reenactment of an episode of the old VH1 Behind the Music series. There are rewards, but many opportunities are missed.

I'll recap the story in a minute, but first let's talk about the part of The Four Seasons that people care about the most: Frankie Valli's voice. Remember when you first heard the lead singer's amazing falsetto, occasionally screeching but mostly swooping higher than you thought possible for a man? Remember how weird it seemed to hear "Walk Like a Man" sung by a guy with a voice that sounded like a girl?

In a New York Times article by Mark Rotella, producer Bob Crewe says that on a night in 1962 when the group ran out of material but the audience wanted more, "Frankie picks up some maracas and does a great imitation of 1940s singer Rose Murphy in a falsetto. It was so clean, so crisp." Composer and band member Bob Guadio was supposedly so inspired by that weird, wonderful falsetto that he went home and wrote the Number 1 hit "Sherry" in 15 minutes. Isn't that interesting? Shame we don't see that in the movie.

The Four Seasons were built on Frankie Valli and that voice, but we never get a real sense of the man behind the high notes. Actor John Lloyd Young does a great job recreating Valli's falsetto, but has a distant look in his eyes that keeps the character separate from the proceedings. Three members of the group address the audience directly (as in the musical), but not Valli. He remains above ... apart.

About the story: The group is formed in 1961, with Valli recruited by his best pal Tommy (Vincent Piazza) to join him and Nick Massi (Michael Lomenda). Later they invite Guadio (Erich Bergen), who co-wrote the hit "Short Shorts," to make it a foursome. After connecting with producer Crewe (well-played by Mike Doyle) the hits start happening, followed by the usual friction and fractures experienced by successful groups. Tommy's debt to a loan shark triggers much of the trouble. Thankfully, the boys' mobster father figure Gyp (Christopher Walken, wonderful as usual) is able to intervene.

So there you go. The plot is routine, with undernourished secondary stories. The bottom line is that the film version of Jersey Boys offers great songs and a satisfying performance by Christopher Walken. Everything else is almost instantly forgettable.


click to enlarge TheSignal_FocusFeatures_Image3_720.jpg

The Signal ★★★ (out of 5) Uneven but interesting low budget sci-fi. Young adults Nic (Brenton Thwaites), his girlfriend Haley (Olivia Cooke) and his best pal Jonah (Beau Knapp) head on a cross country road trip to take Haley to California when they are contacted by a hacker called NOMAD who issues them a challenge. They take NOMAD on it and soon end up at a run-down house in the sticks where things get very weird, but not in the way you might expect. Not a great movie, but a really intriguing one. Laurence Fishburne also appears.

click to enlarge think2.jpg

Think Like a Man Too ★★ Remember the relationship comedy sorta based on Steve Harvey's book? Well, here we go again. The plan is for all the couples from the first movie to spend a weekend in Las Vegas for a big wedding, but all hell breaks loose. Kevin Hart stole the show in the original. He's become a big star since then and the best-in-small-doses comic actor is way overused here. Too much frantic, not enough funny. Of course, if you loved the cast in the first film, you'll probably think I'm full of crap. Michael Ealy, Meagan Good and Regina Hart also appear.


Jersey Boys
Rated R · 134 min. · 2014
Official Site:
Director: Clint Eastwood
Writer: Marshall Brickman
Cast: Christopher Walken, Vincent Piazza, Freya Tingley, Francesca Eastwood, Kathrine Narducci, James Madio and Mike Doyle

Now Playing

Sorry there are no upcoming showtimes for Jersey Boys

Latest in Film + TV

  • Indy Film Talk: Celebrating 'Saw' this Halloween
  • Indy Film Talk: Celebrating 'Saw' this Halloween

    In honor of the 10th anniversary theatrical re-release of Saw, Sam talks about the film's influence with horror directors from around the world.
    • Oct 30, 2014
  • Review: St. Vincent
  • Review: St. Vincent

    An outstanding cast, including a spot-on Bill Murray, elevates St. Vincent above its pedestrian script.
    • Oct 29, 2014
  • Indy Film Talk: Steve James documents "life itself"
  • Indy Film Talk: Steve James documents "life itself"

    Sam talks to some local critics about Steve James's latest film, Life Itself, a documentary portrait of Roger Ebert. James is appearing at Bloomington's IU Cinema this weekend.
    • Oct 24, 2014
  • More »


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

What others are saying (5)

Inlander The Boys’ Band Clint Eastwood takes the Four Seasons to the big screen without missing a beat by Ed Symkus 06/18/2014
Portland Mercury Jazz Hands? Or SAD HANDS? I love all musicals, including Jersey Boys. Sue me, dickheads. by Elinor Jones 06/18/2014
Connect Savannah Review: Jersey Boys An excellent filmmaker when it comes to pensive, low-key dramas, Clint Eastwood never quite locates the proper beat for this tale. by Matt Brunson 07/02/2014
2 more reviews...
Creative Loafing Charlotte Jersey Boys occasionally off-key Rating: **1/2 by Matt Brunson 06/27/2014
LA Weekly Clint Eastwood's Jersey Boys Is Way More Realistic Than the Stage Version If you think summer movies are clamorous, try a current Broadway musical. Watching Jersey Boys onstage is like soldiering through some extreme eating contest where you're force-fed dessert for three hours. It's all falsetto heroics and hustled-through character drama, every beat of every scene over-scored, over-rehearsed and overbearing. And it's... by Alan Scherstuhl 06/19/2014


Recent Comments

More by Ed Johnson-Ott

© 2014 NUVO | Website powered by Foundation