click to enlarge
Ah, the divey Alley Cat has been unseated in this category (previously called Best Place For Hooking Up) for its neighbor around the corner, Wild Beaver Saloon. The Beav actually has two locations: one Downtown, one in Broad Ripple, so you can find love (or lust) in two parts of town. This "Colorado Mountain-themed beaver den" features karaoke and regular drink specials.
20 E. Maryland St., 423-3080; 723 Broad Ripple Ave., 722-0687; wildbeaversaloon.com
2nd: Alley Cat