Boasting 17 tattoo artists (according to their website), Artistic Skin Design and Body Piercing has made sure to plant themselves all over Indy. They have locations on nearly every side of town, and all are filled with talented artists and piercers. (In fact, this editor just got one of her piercings done there.) Go to their website to see styles from each of the artists and to find one who might match what you are looking for. We strongly discourage getting a partner’s name though — for real, it’s the kiss of death.
3rd: Salty Siren Tattoo Lounge