A Michiana meat pie adventure 

click to enlarge A spot of pie from Pleasant House Three Oaks.
  • A spot of pie from Pleasant House Three Oaks.

Having worked for a while at England's most influential restaurant (St. John), Black Market's Micah Frank knows a thing or two about great British food. So when he suggested to me a couple of weeks ago that I check out the best English pies this side of the Atlantic (in, of all places, Three Oaks, Mich.), my wife and I dropped everything and headed north for an impromptu spot of lunch at the first opportunity.

Situated three hours north of Indianapolis, Three Oaks is the kind of place that time might well have forgotten had not a handful of entrepreneurs decided, almost simultaneously it seems, that the nondescript Michiana town was going to become a weekend getaway for city-weary Chicagoans and others of a gastronomically curious bent. Situated in gently undulating farmland amidst wineries and orchards, it's an unlikely yet perfect spot for a food and drink-themed getaway.

Although the Brits love their sweet and fruit pies, it's the savory varieties that the baker's reputation rests upon, and which Chelsea Kalberloh Jackson, co-owner with husband Art, has completely mastered at Pleasant House. Steak pies, their buttery, flaky pastry stuffed with meat and vegetables cooked in an ale sauce, are classics not to be trifled with, yet here they are as perfect in taste and texture as any I have eaten.

Cornish pasties, the tin miner's lunch, are half-moon shaped hand pies that were once rumored to have been filled with meat at one end and fruit at the other. They're so often stale affairs made with cheap puff pastry, yet here they are both robust and tender. The Melton Mowbray pork pie, after which the hat was named, is crafted from a hot lard crust filled with dense pork paté, buffered by a thick layer of wobbly trotter jelly.

Three Oaks' Journeyman Distillery would've been located in Indiana if not for the state's criminally stupid and corrupt blue laws.
  • Three Oaks' Journeyman Distillery would've been located in Indiana if not for the state's criminally stupid and corrupt blue laws.

These are best eaten cold, usually with hot yellow mustard, washed down with a pint of gently hopped pale ale. And as if it wasn't enough to simply make the best English pies I've tasted since my last trip to the UK, Chelsea and her husband Art have rehabbed an absolutely delightful, brick-and beams building on the town's sleepy main street in which to enjoy them.

Purists will also love the authentic, lowish-alcohol  bitter on tap as well as a splendid 4.3 percent stout and a couple of other real ales. All made in house, of course, as are the sodas: a perfect complement to the home-grown produce from the couple's Chicago farm. This is true farm-to fork eating, deliberately limited in scope, but perfectly judged.

After a satisfying meal of pie, mash and peas, I strongly recommend a leisurely stroll down to the Journeyman Distillery, located in a character-laden old warehouse building.  Originally intended to be in Indiana, but impossible to achieve owing to this state's restrictive licensing laws, Journeyman not only micro-distils some remarkably pure and complex whiskies, but also features a tasting room, cocktail bar and limited dining options. Under one roof!

For that reason alone it's worth the drive. On this visit, knowing that the trip back was going to be long, I limited myself to a single, yet sublime, barrel-aged Negroni. Next time we'll spend the night.

Latest in Dining Out

  • Soupremacy: A tiny soup shop on the Circle
  • Soupremacy: A tiny soup shop on the Circle

    It's a small space, but I like Soupremacy's chalk board/tin ceilinged look, its crowded city vibe. And the soup is uniformly good, notably the chicken velvet and roasted red pepper.
    • Apr 2, 2014
  • Vegan Indy
  • Vegan Indy

    Herbivore friendly menus and restaurants abound around our city, but pioneer chefs are pushing toward 100% vegetarian and vegan locales.
    • Mar 31, 2014
  • Fire by the Monon: Good food, great setting
  • Fire by the Monon: Good food, great setting

    After three years and three owners, maybe Fire by the Monon's cursed Broad Ripple location, once home to several failed restaurants, has rid itself of its bad mojo.
    • Mar 19, 2014
  • More »


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment


Recent Comments

  • Vegan Indy
    I manage a local web site (http://indyethnicfood.com/ - now 10 years young) dedicated to 'International…
  • Vegan Indy
    Joining the Indy Veggie Meetup group is an easy way to learn about all the…

Reader Reviews

More by Neil Charles

  • Local food alone can't save us (or not yet)

    In spite of the huge strides the local movement has made, we're likely never going to be independent of essential ingredients grown and raised thousands of miles away.
    • Apr 9, 2014
  • In praise of Thunderbird, a nearly perfect bar

    Fountain Square's Thunderbird is the kind of place where you want to belly up for beers from the intelligent draft list, then wolf down biscuits with duck neck gravy.
    • Mar 5, 2014
  • More »

© 2014 NUVO | Website powered by Foundation