American Pianists Association; Butler U; Eidson-Duckwall Recital Hall; Nov. 16.
Grace Fong may well be on her way to being considered the Dinu Lipatti of the 21st century. Many consider the latter — a Rumanian who died at age 33 of Hodgkin's disease — the greatest pianistic talent of the 20th century. Fong, a slender woman of Asian descent and a winsome smile, performed Monday night as one of two 2009 APA Fellows, awarded last April. Fong moves her fingers over any kind of pianistic passage any composer can conjure up with seemingly absolute effortlessness, while shaping and phrasing any kind of structure with perfection and ultimate musicality. She is above being a mere virtuoso — she occupies a lofty stratosphere of her own making. Fong opened with Prokofiev’s very early Sonata No. 1 in F Minor, Op. 1 (1909) — written when he was 18. Though mostly loud and boisterous, it sounds much more like Chopin than Prokofiev, but Fong made it interesting, almost magical. She did the same with her program’s final work, the Carl Vine Sonata No. 1 (1990) — a piece she repeated from her APA Premiere-Series appearance a year ago — though the two works could hardly be more contrasting in style. This work, filled with modernist punctuations — including Fong’s forearm striking the keyboard, impressed me a bit more than a year ago. In between, Fong played two Chopin impromptus, his Tarantella, Op. 43, Liszt’s show-offy Ballade No. 2 in B Minor and Mozart’s Variations on “Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star,” K. 265. All these pieces, in bearing Fong’s special stamp, also revealed their composers as few other performers can do.

Comments
Simply Remarkable
Posted by Margaret WilliamsFri, 11/20/2009 - 5:36pm
I'll have to agree on an utterly stunning recital!
hypnosis
Posted by jung leeFri, 11/20/2009 - 12:39pm
Even on that monster of a piano in Eidson, Dr. Fong has the most magical sound of anyone I have ever heard!
Grace Fong's return
Posted by Brandon SrourFri, 11/20/2009 - 12:45am
I have tried to catch every return performance of Grace Fong in Indianapolis, and she never fails to deliver the most heartfelt performances--the tears and immediate standing ovation from the audience Monday say it all.
I disagree
Posted by Michael P ScottThu, 11/19/2009 - 12:41am
Grace Fong, APA laureate that she is, seemed in loud fettle on November 16 and to compare her to Dinu Lipatti is truly astonishing. There IS no comparison.
Ms. Fong's playing -- whether because of the acoustics of the Eidson-Duckwall Recital Hall, or the overly bright piano tuning -- was remarkable for its tendency to maintain one straight line level of volume: loud.
The Prokofiev, which she played at the APA's 30th Anniversary Gala the week before, was quite different from the Prokofiev we generally know. But it was loud and bangy.
Her Chopin sounded like Prokofiev; her Liszt sounded like Liszt on steroids and her Mozart (with variations out of order and overly ornamented) sounded like Liszt.
Her performance was marred by an overtly mannered approach -- really distracting.
Her encore, Schumann's Traumerei, was as far removed from Horowitz (or Lipatti) as possible -- again overly mannered.
Ms. Fong has the fingers, there's no contesting that. She does NOT have the maturity or the nuance that one would expect from a truly fine pianist.