Why does America hate soccer?
by Steve Hammer Jul 18, 2007
With or without Beckham, we yawn
David Beckham arrived in America last week to one of the biggest receptions for a British import since the Beatles landed in New York some 43 years ago.
His picture, and that of his wife’s, has been in every newspaper, on all the celebrity-based TV shows and all over the Web. Before even playing a game, he’s single-handedly made the Los Angeles Galaxy a worldwide brand name.
When he takes the pitch this weekend in an exhibition game against the great British team Chelsea, much of the world will be watching on television.
Beckham and the Galaxy will doubtlessly remain media curiosities for a while, but the bigger question is whether this move will signal an era of greater popularity stateside for soccer, the most popular sport in the world.
Are Americans ready to become passionate about soccer in the same way they are about football, basketball and NASCAR? Probably not.
There are several things going against soccer turning into a favorite American sport. One of the biggest is its unsuitability for television. The game only stops at the end of the first half, meaning there’s no opportunity for networks to sell beer, car and Viagra advertising to run every five minutes.
Our pro football games have 19 or more 90-second advertising windows per game. College football has 13 such windows. Baseball and basketball each have 20 or more. With far fewer opportunities to make money, networks will no doubt balk at carrying soccer games except on rare occasions.
The other, more important, reason that America will not embrace soccer, at least in the short term: We suck at it.
In World Cup after World Cup, our teams — or our men’s teams, at least — get pummeled by much smaller countries. We never win anything and our team usually embarrasses itself in the process.
In our sports, like our wars, we stop caring about them once we start losing. Unless and until our national team starts beating England and Brazil, and our drunken fans can shout, “USA! USA!” at matches, it’s unlikely that we’ll pay attention to the game of soccer.
And, except for Beckham, our teams haven’t had the money to lure top international stars to play in Major League Soccer.
I’ve read analysis from experts that the level of play in the MLS is on par with the British Conference Two league, which is three levels from the top, or equivalent to single-A baseball or Division Two college ball in the states.
That means teams such as Accrington Stanley and Rochdale, British squads full of 17-year-olds and washed-up players, could probably beat the crap out of the Houston Dynamo or the New York Red Bulls.
Americans don’t like it when foreigners do something better than we can; it’s just as simple as that.
But it’s too bad that soccer will never unseat football in the hearts of my countrymen, because it’s an exciting and complex sport with many nuances, at least in the elite leagues, such as the British Premier League and the Italian Serie A league.
After watching Inter Milan take on AC Milan, or Chelsea play Manchester United, watching the MLS is like watching Little League baseball. It’s the same sport, but one that’s played at a much lower level.
As a lifelong NFL and NBA fan, I have to admit I paid more attention to soccer than either football or basketball last year. I became frustrated with the length of time it took to play, angry with all of the breaks in the action and the subsequent commercials, and the relative lack of excitement.
Even when nothing appears to be happening in soccer, many things are going on. There’s the jostling for position, the patient assembly of a scoring opportunity or just somebody being bodyslammed into the grass.
Too much time is spent on utter nothingness in football, with players running off the field, with guys just standing around, with John Madden talking about the fine ribs he ate the night before.
Baseball is so full of cheating and scandals that it lost its credibility years ago. The all-time home run record is about to be broken and not that many people care about it.
What does it say about America that we willingly spend time watching millionaire athletes doing nothing? The average baseball and football game lasts well over three hours, with basketball not too far behind.
A pro soccer game lasts 90 minutes, plus 15 minutes for halftime. Unless it’s a championship game where extra time is added for a tied match, it ends on schedule, even when fans are throwing bottles and rocks at the players.
At any rate, while Beckham might not be the savior of American soccer, anything that gets people more aware of the sport is a good thing. Perhaps someday Americans will realize just what a great sport they’re missing.
Comments on Why does America hate soccer?
Americans hate soccer for the same reason the whole world hates American football
by James | Mar 29, 2008
Ask any italian or german or brazilian or chinese or indonesian or [insert nationality that isn't american here] about the NFL and american football.
Their response will be: American football is boring, no one likes it, very uncool sport.
You get the same response regarding soccer from america. People find what isn't their culture to be "boring".
Report this comment
Soccer
by Martin Z | Feb 29, 2008
I am English and everyone tells me that we designed the sport (i somewhat doubt). Unfortunately soccer is slow and uneventfull. It also encourages hooligans - dont know why but its a fact. You may have stopages in the American sports but when in play you have to pay attention all the time unlike soccer.
Report this comment
Soccer is great fun!
by milla | Aug 2, 2007
I am an American woman who grew up overseas, playing soccer (poorly), listening to games on the radio, and watching them on TV. Whoever thinks the sport is boring hasn't taken the time to learn the game and its strategies. I believe Americans don't like soccer because it's more of a team sport, not a one-man show—as men's professional basketball seems to have turned into. In soccer, one person can't take the ball from one end of the field to the other and score, like you can in basketball. Americans seem to associate skill with scoring, but a limited number of soccer players are in positions where scoring is easily accomplished. Soccer at its most beautiful is an art; there are many people playing on the field but only a few artists. There are some great soccer players, but few beyond the ones scoring get any recognition in the US.
I also really don't understand the problem with televising. Countries all over the world have the commentators put in the advertising plugs whenever they can during the match.
Report this comment
USA did win the Gold Cup
by Jade | Jul 29, 2007
We did defeat Mexico 2-1 for the Gold Cup at the end of June for the second consecutive year, despite US fans were out ranked 25 to 1. So the quote "We never win anything and our team usually embarrasses itself in the process." is crap! Also, I wish people would talk about Landon Donovan who is a great American soccer player and quit being up English David Beckhams bum! Soccer is so under appreciated... can you run for that long period of time without stopping and try to get a goal while defending yours? Americans are fat and can't stand to watch people run!
Report this comment
Americans hate soccer because
by joj | Jul 27, 2007
Well, I don't think soccer/football is as hated as you would have us believe. I agree with much of what Mr. Hammer says about American sports. However, he runs to absurdities whenever he states "experts" say MLS is minor league. Not the top league in the world, that is true. But "Little League"? Oh, come now. You might want to know that the great Pele himself has been quoted as saying the league is much tougher than the dismissive Euro press claims. I would take his word over these "experts" mentioned. I follow MLS and I can tell you that it is not all that much inferior than a middle bracket Premier team. Say, Wiggan? I don't know what you can say when Chelsea was beaten by the MLS all stars last year. And even though it was preseason for these great players don't forget the MLS team HAD NEVER played together as a team!
Football/soccer is a sport where the attack is always on. This is what most Americans fail to understand. It never stops...ever.
Follow the MLS and get into it. I think you will find, as any sport, there are games that are woeful, but more than not they are very entertaining and the skill level is far greater than people realize.
Report this comment
soccer
by backtalker | Jul 25, 2007
I don't think Americans "hate" soccer. They simply are indifferent to it. It's not a high-scoring, highly commercialized product like (American) football or Basketball.
As a parent of two kids who have been playing soccer since they were toddlers, I can say that I would MUCH rather go to a soccer game than a Pacers, Fever or Colts game.
I believe that kids who are growing up today will have a much better appreciation for the game than kids of my generation. I never saw a soccer ball until I was in my 20's.
Report this comment
yes...BUT
by Tommy | Jul 25, 2007
Soccer in america is starting to get better ratings than baseball on a regular basis. The copa america games buried last years baeball playoffs.
we don't hate soccer...the corperations do because they have a hard time whoring it out. thus, we've been told to hate it.
Report this comment
Beckham can't save it, but there is a future
by Corrie Jagger | Jul 24, 2007
Growing up in Indiana, I remember having two team sports with any real community connection and support behind them - baseball and basketball. Soccer and swimming were sports that required a bit of money behind it to allow involvement - YMCA or private club memberships, lessons, summer camp exposure, etc. Soccer was inaccessible and exotic to me and my friends and to those I knew and encountered growing up in Indiana. The same is true in many areas of the United States. The inaccessibility of soccer is a primary reason for its relative lack of break through success in the United States, in my opinion.
This is all slowly beginning to change though. The generation of kids after me and those just slightly younger than me as well as the kids of today are raised with soccer as a primary focus in their group sport activity. There is still a drop in accessibility to the sport once kids out grow the youth leagues that are so standard now in every community. This leads to a gradual decline in involvement and subsequent disinterest later on. I think this is all very important in realizing why soccer here simply isn’t what it is elevated to in the rest of the world.
In the UK and all of Europe, soccer or football clubs are local institutions and every region has a club with a passionate legacy of followers. Regional loyalties and the rivalries that grow between close neighbors are things that get in to the blood of those raised in these environments. The rivalries are clan like and based powerfully and primarily upon where you were born and or raised. The nationalistic following of teams in Europe in the rest of the world makes sense with that one factor taken in to consideration. Here, in a spread out, huge country with endless sporting options, the vital regional and nationalistic link to the sport is lost and lost on the fans. We don’t attach our identity to a soccer club and our national loyalties can be spread out over many different sports, ie college sports of all kinds, the NBA, NFL, etc. Elsewhere, soccer is tied in to personal identity in a way that can’t really be fathomed unless you have been abroad and experienced it. For these reasons, I think that the elevation of soccer to a national past time and passion on par with the rest of the world is far off in the future, if it happens at all. Keep in mind, Pele, one of the greatest ever, couldn’t elevate the sport here in a way that even kept professional clubs viable in the 70’s.
For now, Beckham will be regarded as a beautiful novelty in the twilight of his career. Here’s hoping his ankles and general physical health can be maintained in good health that keeps him in top form necessary to keep or draw the fickle American interest.
Report this comment
Soccer
by World per diverdave | Jul 23, 2007
I do not hate the game but I do find it to be a bit boring. Why must we love it? The athletes are skilled and have refined their talents, an enviable talent. Bowling also takes a lot of practice and skill but it too is boring and I do not watch it either.
Report this comment
Americans hate soccer because
by Tom | Jul 23, 2007
Low scoring, not only that but lots of missed shots. Try watching a women basketball game, lots of shots and lots of misses. American suck at soccer because our great athletes are playing other sports, other wise we would dominate. Right now most kids in America that play soccer are there because they couldn't make the baseball or football teams.
Report this comment
Americans hate soccer because...
by Dee Willie | Jul 22, 2007
1) Americans have a VERY SHORT attention span, they want EVERYTHING yesterday.
2) There are no cheerleaders in soccer, which mean the fans don't have any sets of titties and asses to watch when there is a TV timeout.
3) Soccer requires ALOT of teamwork, which goes against the grain for american sports. (Unless you are talking about the high school and college level)
Americans hate soccer, because..... I could on here, but I won't.By the way, before all the chest thumping flag wavers start on a rant, I am an American.
Report this comment
hilarious
by me | Jul 22, 2007
I tuned to ESPN last night and found they were showing the Galaxy vs. Chelsea game. It was hilarious. The Galaxy sucks. They suck worse than a Rod Dowhower coached Colts team. They are going to get their ass kicked day after day against anybody outside of Little League. I predict that the major interest when the Galaxy plays will be wagering on which opposing player will stomp on Beckham’s ankle to put an aging has been player out of action for good. Now that would be a thrill for any soccer player. It would be like lighting a Cuban cigar with a $250 million bill.
Report this comment
Little League
by me | Jul 19, 2007
I was ready to dismiss this Beckham thing as a meaningless publicity stunt. Because even if Beckham's team wins in the MLS, it's still just a minor league, despite the name. But apparently the owner of the Galaxy is setting up games with real soccer teams. When the Galaxy starts beating teams like Real Madrid and Manchester United then maybe this will mean something. And if ESPN and the average sports fan in the USA ignores it, so what.
Report this comment
Americans hate soccer because it is boring
by Steven W | Jul 18, 2007
I would rate soccer right around men's figure skating or celebrity bowling in excitement. Call me Mr. Short Attention Span but it is really hard to get excited about a game where the final score is probably likely to be 1-0 after two hours! Who cares if the athletes spend most of their time jostling for position or planning a strategy - whats boring is boring.
Report this comment
Post a comment