Web exclusive: Bob Dylan at the Lawn

Where

Lawn At White River Park
801 W. Washington St
, IN 46204
Recent stories by
Jeff Napier
Web exclusive: The Hives and Jack Oblivian
May 14, 2008
Hot Buttered Rum
May 7, 2008
The Booze, Red Light Driver, Noah East
Apr 16, 2008
Web exclusive: Naptown Juke Stomp
Apr 8, 2008
Cocaine Wolves craft future hard rock classics
Apr 2, 2008


Recommended stories

Book Reviews
Bringing it all back home
by Steve Hammer
May 31, 2006

Music
Picking up where Scorsese left off
by David Hoppe
Aug 30, 2006

Letters
Bob Dylan, redux
by Letter to the Editor
May 2, 2007

Show Previews
Bob Dylan, Jimmie Vaughan
by Jeff Napier
Jul 11, 2007

Show Previews
Dylan, Costello play Bloomington
by Jimmy Rae
Oct 17, 2007

Music
Downtown new site for concert venue
by Jim Walker
Nov 19, 2003


Web exclusive: Bob Dylan at the Lawn
by Jeff Napier Jul 17, 2007

 

Bob Dylan
The Lawn at White River State Park
Sunday, July 15


The last time I saw Bob Dylan, playing to a Deer Creek full of hippies waiting for Phil Lesh, he displayed the worst tendencies of his recent past, never leaving the keyboard to pick up a guitar and doing a lackluster set list of songs that muddled into one another with no, um, direction home. This past Sunday, when Bob showed up in Indianapolis again at the Lawn at White River State Park, he was an entirely different animal.

He still carried a faceless, bland backing band that simply did what was required — no more, no less. Dylan still looked like an old Jew in a cowboy hat, but his performance was on fire, edgy and raw, with his rough vocal growl summoning up demons from 40 years of hard work. It wasn’t Dylan in his prime to be sure, but it was as good as we could ever possibly hope to get from Modern Times Zimmerman.

He pulled out only a smattering of recent tunes, including Modern Times’ “Thunder On The Mountain,” a joyful old-time rock and roll romp that kicked off the encore and a picture-perfect version of “Summer Days” from Love & Theft. The rest of the set, Bob and his band took us on a way-back trip, pulling out old standards and crowd favorites.

Dylan started the set off on electric guitar and plowed through a bluesy, rollicking “Rainy Day Woman #12 & 35” and went on to pull out nugget after nugget from his catalogue. “Lay Lady Lay” and “Tangled Up In Blue” were rarely played numbers that stuck pretty close to their original arrangements, while others like “It Ain’t Me Babe” and “I Shall Be Released” took a few measures for the crowd to understand what he was singing, but still managed to hold the passion and soul that made them so special in the first place.

All through the set Dylan’s voice was a train wreck of growls and grunts, kinda like Tom Waits with marbles in his mouth, and the band was nothing special, seemingly realizing what most of the songs were when the audience did. Yet, despite all of that, Dylan gave the diverse crowd of old and young hipsters one of the best and most vital shows he’s given anywhere in a long time.

 

Comments on Web exclusive: Bob Dylan at the Lawn
Bob Dylan at The Lawn
by Marshall Craig Walker | Jul 23, 2007

After a 42 year wait, since Bob picked up an electric guitar and played "Maggie's Farm," I've waited for the moment to see him with a band. Jimmie Vaughn opened, outdoors, the guest of 6,000 people and a beautiful night. Mid-way through Jimmie's set he introduced Lou Ann Barton!!!!!!!! I was beside myself. He sprung to life in the support role, which I feel is his strong suit, and they nailed the 45 minutes they had been allotted.    20 minutes later, Bob Dylan and his pathetic ensemble took the stage. It was the most awful performance I've EVER seen or heard. These yocals must dress in cowboy suits so no one will beat the crap out of them when they are recognized on the street! Bob was just horrid. Totally unprofessional, sloppy, his band couldn't play worth beans and I understood one word in the first 25 minutes, well, maybe two, depending on whether you consider "New York" one word or two. I am afraid any young MBA will see this as bolstering his/her position that someone with 45+ years experience can NOT get the job done. I may have to have AARP sue him, on our behalf! With all due respect, the show was not good. I am so sorry to admit this fact, since I am a complete Dylan fanatic, though not an idol worshipper of any sort. One should strain to understand the meaning, not the lyric. The lyric lasts but a syllable or two while the thinking goes on forever, as long as the lyric is discernible from the onset. The lyric, too, may be presented within any context the artist wishes to set it, but, this too was a failure on Bob's, and his band's, part. I've listened to Sandy Denny cover Dylan and who knows how many other thousands of versions and artists, all expressed as the artist wishes. That is the mark of a solid song and the mark of an even more solid and brilliant writer, such as Dylan, of course. A performer, though? That's iffy, at best. When I spend money, and we spent good money for this, I expect something in return. This time, "Nothing was Delivered." Between "Love and Theft," this was theft. I did not, however, pitch my CDs out the window of my car on our return home. I love the records, always have and always will and that is the reason I wanted to see him, not because he was going to perform just like the record, which would bore me to tears, rather with the hope that he would re-invent the songs and present them with authority which escaped him, this night, maybe due to a "Simple Twist of Fate." Marshall Craig Walker

Report this comment

NOTE: Comments posted to our web site may be used our "letter to the editor" section of the paper.

Post a comment
/ to /
May 15, 2008
Indiana State Museum
Miki Mathioudakis as the legendary 19th century Appalachian quilter Aunt Jane in a one-woman play by Rita Kohn. As she begins to make one last quilt, Aunt ...
Should Hillary Clinton drop out of the primary race?
Yes
No













Myspace



© 2007 NUVO, Inc.
Contact Us