Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Daniel Radcliffe returns in the title role of 'Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix'
Recent stories by
Ed Johnson-Ott
Also on DVD for 9/3/08
Sep 3, 2008
Then She Found Me
Sep 3, 2008
Until Thanksgiving
Sep 3, 2008
The Office: Season Four
Sep 3, 2008
Reprise
Sep 3, 2008


Recommended stories

Show Previews
Harry and the Potters with Draco and the Malfoys
by Wade Coggeshall
Jul 25, 2007

DVD
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
by Ed Johnson-Ott
Dec 12, 2007


Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
by Ed Johnson-Ott Jul 11, 2007

Three stars (PG-13)

Holy smokes, Hogwarts has been taken over by Republicans! Paranoia, alienation and angst abound in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, where it appears that the bleak shall inherit the earth. Remember the images of exuberant youngsters flying through the sunny skies from earlier films in the series? Treasure those memories, because currently the smiles are fleeting, the palette is as dark as the mood and the kids are most certainly not all right.

Of course, none of this is news to the Potter faithful, who have already read the book on which this is based as well as the one that follows it, and are eagerly awaiting the seventh, and supposedly final, J.K. Rowling novel about the teen wizard and his comrades.

I’m not one of the faithful. I’ve seen each of the Potter films once and appreciated them all, while preferring the latter productions. Though I recognize that each installment represents part of an epic story arc, my relative lack of familiarity means I can only assess this as a standalone movie.

Despite being taken aback at how dark life has become in The Order of the Phoenix, I enjoyed the film, though not as much as the last two. Harry’s estrangement from pretty much everybody casts a pall over the movie — and yes, I understand that that’s how the story is structured, but there were moments where I wanted to grab the young wizard by the shoulders and shout, “Lighten up! Take a nap, have a snack, go play that game where everybody flies around trying to get balls through hoops, just stop moping and glowering!”

I won’t go into all the details about why Harry (Daniel Radcliffe) is so damn grim. Suffice to say, he knows that all hell is about to break loose. Of course, the powers that be won’t listen to his warnings. Close friends Ron (Rupert Grint) and Hermione (Emma Watson) try to be supportive, but Harry’s attitude makes it almost impossible to connect.

While Harry glowers, Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry is experiencing major staffing problems. The great Imelda Staunton (Vera Drake) joins the massive cast of renowned British actors as instructor Delores Umbridge, who looks like your sweet old aunt and behaves like Brian Bosma. Delores sets out to make Hogwarts as prim and proper as she considers herself to be, using her powers, political clout and natural bullying skills to try to extinguish the fire of the students. The escalating conflict between her and a handful of rebellious teens provides some of the most entertaining scenes in the film. Inserted into all of this is a sorta-romance for Harry, culminating in a first kiss that packs scant emotional punch because the relationship is unconvincing.

Luckily, all the gloom and doom builds to some major confrontations, as director David Yates and company provide some wow moments and a respite from all the exposition. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix pays off well enough to almost make up for the excessive yakking. The depressing tone grows tiresome at times, but at least it leads to a rewarding climax.

Comments on Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
more on morons
by purist | Jul 12, 2007

i believe ed reviewed the movie, because it is a movie. i believe a review of the book would be a book review and most likely not be in the movie review section. duh.

Report this comment

moron this
by lldavids44 | Jul 11, 2007

hate to say it but while i am really mainly a fan of the books i LOVED the movie and one of the reasons is because there wasn't nearly as much whining and moping as in the books. i was disappointed they left out the weasley twins coup de grace but liked the mood and storytelling and the 3d at imax even more!

Report this comment

moron
by me | Jul 11, 2007

its clear you haven't read the books, and until you do, you should really refrain from writing a review on the movie, their are reasons beyond your understanding why harry is acting the way he is. That is a perk for those who have taken the time to read these books and can fully appreciate what the underlying problems are. Read the books, watch the movies, then write... maybe you will get it correct next time.

Report this comment

NOTE: Comments posted to our web site may be used our "letter to the editor" section of the paper.

Post a comment
/ to /
Sep 5, 2008
Herron School of Art and Design
Thirty-two works of art -- rhinestone embellished mixed media images -- by renowned artist Thomas Woodruff. Aug. 8-Oct. 4. Public reception Sept. 5, 5-8 p...
Should Indiana retailers be allowed to sell alcohol on Sundays?
Yes
No













Myspace





© 2007 NUVO, Inc.
Contact Us