Posted on May 17, 2006  /    Email to a friend   /    Comments (closed)
"); ?> Printer-friendly version

LETTERS

A privilege, not a right

I hate to prick a pin into the balloon of noted constitutional scholar and public safety expert Steve Hammer, but I feel I have no choice (Hammer, “Traffic Ticket Raises Questions,” May 10-17). For starters, driving an automobile is technically a privilege, not a right. Decades of court precedent says that the states have the right to determine operational rules for their drivers. I’m slightly alarmed that Steve repeated the oft-repeated canard that flying through the windshield is actually preferable to a seat belt. The notion that all sorts of people are trapped in burning cars by their seat belts is something that you see in a movie, or hear about in an urban legend. Although I suppose not wearing a seat belt helps you escape when the man with a hook for a hand pops out from the back seat.  

If you’re lucky enough to survive being thrown through a windshield and onto the concrete, at great force I might add, you face a lifetime of crippling medical conditions and expenses. Eventually these will put you on the public dime. So, while you prattle on about personal choice, eventually society as a whole has to pick up the pieces of said choice. Do us a favor, Steve, and stick to walking.

Peter Miesel
Indianapolis

"); print(""); print("CLICK HERE TO VIEW THE COVER STORY ARCHIVES
"); } if ($category == "HOPPE") { print(""); } if ($category == "HAMMER") { print(""); } if ($category == "NEWS") { print(""); } if ($category == "HUMOR/SATIRE") { print(""); } if ($category == "COLUMNS") { print(""); } if ($category == "LETTERS") { print(""); } if ($category == "CUISINE") { print(""); } if ($category == "DVD IN STORES") { print(""); } if ($category == "EXTRAS") { print(""); } if ($category == "INDY EATS") { print(""); } if ($category == "MOVIE SHORT REVIEWS") { print(""); } if ($category == "MOVIES") { print(""); } if ($category == "MUSIC") { print(""); } if ($category == "MUSIC PREVIEWS") { print(""); } if ($category == "MUSIC REVIEWS") { print(""); } if ($category == "PREVIEWS") { print(""); } if ($category == "REVIEWS") { print(""); } if ($category == "SPORTS") { print(""); } ?>